Scroll saw vs Band saw?
Band saw vs Scroll saw?
Your scroll saw vs band saw- what’s the difference? The debate has a quite easy and loud answer, and that is the blade. So, it particularly depends on the type of cutting you need to do.
Even though both the saws look quite alike, still, their work style is not the same. If you are a practicing Carpenter, you might already have both; but, if you are a newbie, choose according to your need.
I will be writing about the structure of the saws, their specialties, and most importantly, the difference between a scroll saw and band saw.
Before going to the band saw vs scroll saw detail, let me show the similarity between these two. Like a band saw, a scroll saw also has a table. Both the saws come with a blade that runs through the center of the table.
Band saw vs Scroll saw: The blade
The difference between a scroll saw and saw lies in the blade.
Scroll saw blades are particularly loved for their thin, short blade that is a sturdy detail worker. You can move it up and down quickly. The most exciting part to me is, a scroll saw blade can dive inside to make my crafts extraordinary. Despite these goodies, a scroll saw blade cannot be the only thing you have if you are a carpenter or professional. Because of the small height and width of the blade, it cannot do heavy task like a band saw.
There are various types of scroll saw blade depending on size, cutting style, material and other considerations. These different blades play several diverse functions. Here are the seven types of scroll saw blade you need to know about.
- Standard Tooth Blades
- Reverse Skip-Tooth Blades
- Precision Ground Blades
- Skip-Tooth Blades
- Double-Tooth Blades
- Crown Tooth Blades
The blade that comes with the same size teeth with the same distance apart is known as a standard tooth blade. These teeth face the same direction. This type of blade also comes in two ways—one for cutting wood and another for metal cutting. The metal cutting blade has smaller teeth, while the distance is even shorter.
The skip tooth blades have much more gap in between the teeth. It is named skip tooth because of the full tooth gap. The beginner mostly uses these types of saws as it cuts fast, but the wider gap creates pain for not being able to remove sawdust while cutting.
Double tooth blades come with a skipper tooth after each pair of teeth, and the gap is also much wider than usual. This design makes it a variant of standard teeth blade. This blade will give you a very smooth finishing that you would not need further sanding.
Reverse skip tooth blade has similar spacing as a usual skip tooth blade, but half of the teeth of this blade face the opposite side. It means half teeth are faced upside while the others are facing downward. This design helps the knife to cut upside and downside to add more details in your creation, giving you the desired outcome.
Precision ground blades have nothing unique or different in the teeth, but this blade has a way thinner front to back which is not usually seen in other blades. With this narrower portion, you can do precise works that are tight and requires fine cutting.
Spiral blades are about twisting teeth that allow you to cut in any direction without moving your material. These type of blades are for rough work and not precise.
A new type is the crown tooth blade in the market. This blade can cut upstroke and down stroke with the teeth having two points that are placed facing the opposite direction. This design gives a crown shape on each tooth.
On the other hand, a band saw blade is kind of a big deal. It works with a smooth motion towards downward as long as you want since the blade is not as small as scroll saws. You have got a consistent flexible that cuts through without limiting you to a certain length.
So, we may come to the point of understanding that; a scroll saw blade is the arm to cater your woodwork while a powerful band saw will make big cuts done in a minute. A band saw may sometimes do the detail works, but you would love them for their sturdy outside and rip cutting performance.
Scroll Saw Comparison With Band Saw on Works
A scroll saw is best for artwork. The narrow blade can go in every desired way to make various beautiful crafty and small cuts. A thin blade can make the tight cut but a wide blade is good for rip cut, so scroll saw blade performs well in curve cutting procedure while cannot make it through for a rip cut.
The thin blade can cut from the middle part of a work piece. If you want to make anything from the mid part of any wood, with the scroll saw blade, you can make the cutout which is not possible with a band saw. You have to use this highly detailed artwork or project out of wood.
So, you cannot help but buy a scroll saw for your special projects that require curve, circular, inside or other detailed work.
Band Saw Comparison with Scroll Saw on Work
While a scroll saw is the best for small cuts and can make various shapes out of wood, a band saw can do all kind of works in thick materials. Most importantly a band saw can do massive works which are not possible with a small blade as a scroll saw. Now, there are also different types of band saws for different kinds of assignments.
If you are looking for a portable band saw, you can choose a bench top band which is small and portable. These types of saws are mostly used by the contractors and woodworkers who have to carry the tool with them always. Even though these saws are small, they are very much capable of doing a heavy task. These bench top band saws can make big curves, rip cuts and you can work on thick woods with these saws.
Then there come stationary band saws. Stationary band saws have a wider blade, and powerful motor than the little bench top band saw. As a result, this one can cut through much thicker materials; you get a smooth and easy rip cut with this heavy-duty cutting tool.
Resaw band saws are even stronger and prominent than a stationary band saw. These saws are made with a strong motor and wider blade which is generally very good for straight cuts. These types of saws can do curve cuts but not as fine as a scroll saw since its blade is too wider to make small arcs. So if you need to do resaw, this one is yours.
Scroll Saw vs Band Saw: Budget!
You cannot forget about your budget for buying the best saw. In this part, I must mention that we should not buy a bad quality saw for saving money. Then again I should say that, if you do not intend to use this saw regular, but for once or twice, you may not want to spend a lot of money behind it. But yes, if you are buying for everyday use, you should not hesitate to buy a costly one because it has to endure the daily load.
Now, you might be thinking about which one is expensive and which you can afford. Well, typically a scroll saw is much lower in the budget than a band saw and this is legit because professionals use this band saw for their work.
A band saw has a more powerful motor and more giant blades which make them do the powerful tasks on various materials, so if you are going to be a regular user, you might want to spend on this for your work to be done great. On the other hand, if you are to work on fine, intricate work where a band saw cannot help, you have to go for a scroll saw, so budget is not the primary concern here.
Another important thing is the noise. A scroll saw is decent in this case where a band saw could be quite a bit noisy if that matters to you.
In this band saw vs scroll saw decision making you have already understood that the difference between a scroll saw and band saw is in the blade. Two of the saws are for totally different work and which one you should buy depends on your project. There are also different variations in the blades and their working ability. This article tries to give you an idea about the saws so that your confusion vanishes and you can take the right decision!